Thursday, March 26, 2009

Starting the Seder Early

The Torah preserves a somewhat complex account of the timing of the Exodus from Egypt. According to Shemot 12:29-34, as the final plague hits in the middle of the night, striking down the Egyptian first born, the people are thrown out of Egypt immediately. [This confirms the prediction offered by Moshe in Shemot 11:4-8.] No date is given here, but Devarim 16:1 similarly recalls a nighttime Exodus and identifies the date of the Exodus as חדש האביב or the new moon of Aviv, the month we know of as Nisan. [This date is also supplied by Shemot 13:4, 23:15 and 34:18.] In accordance with this memory, Devarim 16:4,6 specifies that the פסח sacrifice must be offered בערב, once the sun has set, so as to coincide with the time of day when the Exodus happened. [It seems that the point is not that this sacrifice must be offered or eaten at midnight, but that it is sufficient to do so sometime after the sun has set, thus locating the ritual in the night as opposed to the day.]

Shemot 12:1-28 describes the Israelites as slaughtering a special lamb on the 14th of the first month (again, Nisan), at the time of day described as בין הערבים—which is understood in rabbinic tradition to refer to the afternoon. They are then to remain indoors all night, waiting for the Egyptian first born to be smitten so that they can leave triumphantly in the morning. [This account of a triumphant morning depature on the 15th as opposed to a midnight escape is also supplied by Shemot 14:8 and Bemidbar 33:3-4.] This passage also specifies that the lamb to be eaten as part of the nightlong vigil must be eaten at night, though the term בערב is also used to describe the time when matzah should be eaten by future generations.

This complex narrative evoked several rabbinic attempts at harmonization. For one example, see Berakhot 9b. Most important, however, all of the above passages agree that the Egyptian first-born were killed at night and that the sacrificial meal commemorating this event had to take place בערב or בלילה, as opposed to during the day. [See Mishnah Zevahim 5:8.] Since matzah and maror are linked to the Pesah offering by Shemot 12:8, they also may not be eaten until it is nighttime. Tosefta Pesahim 2:22 confirms this point. [Interestingly, that text also emphasizes that one should eat those foods as soon after nightfall as possible.]

A separate consideration from the eating of these ritual foods is the retelling of the Exodus that rabbinic sources assume to be a core part of the observance of Pesah. The Pesah sacrifice was not only a celebratory family meal, it was also meant to be a reaffirmation of the national story. For Hazal, this part of the ritual was anchored in Shemot 13:8, which imagines a parent explaining to a child that the annual Pesah sacrifice is on account of the fact that God “took me out of Egypt.” This verse becomes the basis for the idea of the obligation to tell the story once a year. But since Shemot 13 speaks of the Exodus has happening on the new month of Aviv, this begs the question of when it is acceptable to tell this story.

Mekhilta dR. Yishmael Bo Pisha 17 entertains the possibility that this obligation to tell the story would be valid starting with Rosh Hodesh Nisan, in accordance with the plain sense of Shemot 13, but creatively resorting to the phrase ביום ההוא (on that day) in Shemot 13:8—which probably originally meant “at that future time”—the Mekhilta rejects any telling before the 14th of Nisan, which is the rabbinically accepted day for offering the Pesah sacrifice. The Mekhilta then asks whether one could tell the story on the day of the 14th of Nisan, rather than waiting for nightfall. The conclusion: the phrase בעבור זה (on account of this) demands that the telling be done when one can point to the full complement of ritual foods—the matzah and maror. Since these are only to be eaten at night—following Shemot 12:8’s description—the accompanying narrative ritual must happen at night as well.

We thus get a fairly uniform picture of a Seder ritual that must include the telling of the story along with the ritual of eating matzah and maror after nightfall. Since rabbinic tradition always deals stringently with twilight in the context of biblical mitzvot, this would seem to translate into waiting until the stars come out to begin the telling of the story.

Nonetheless, in the middle ages, an important question arises: Can one start Yom Tov early, treating the time before nightfall as the 15th of Nisan for ritual purposes and thereby eat matzah before nightfall? Indeed, Berakhot 27a reports that Rav used to pray Shabbat Arvit on Friday afternoon, well before nightfall (and seemingly even before sunset). This suggests that Shabbat can be begun early and the subsequent daylight hours can count as Shabbat. Can one do the same for Pesah?

R. Yaakov of Corbeil (12th-13th c., in Tosafot Pesahim 99b s.v. ad) argues that even though on most Shabbat and Yom Tov evenings one is permitted to begin the festive meal earlier, while there is still daylight, on Pesah the meal is tied to the Pesah offering, which means that the matzah and maror eaten at the start of the meal may not be consumed until nightfall. He cites Tosefta Pesahim 2:22 as proof of this position. [For more on the question of starting Shabbat meals early, see, among other sources, Terumat Hadeshen #1 and Bah’s citation of Maharal of Prague on OH 472.] R. Yehudah Sirleon (12th-13th c., see his Tosafot on Berakhot 27a) rejects this proof: It might be that the Tosefta is only clarifying that the Pesah offering is not to be consumed on the 14th, but rather on the 15th. [Every other sacrifice can be eaten right away on the day when it was slaughtered, such that this novel point must be made to clarify the Pesah offering’s uniqueness.] In other words, the Tosefta’s stipulation of משתחשך for the time to consume Pesah, matzah and maror is not about astronomy, rather it is about the proper ritual calendrical frame. As long as one has ritually begun the 15th of Nisan—by lighting candles, saying Kiddush or otherwise mentally accepting Yom Tov—one can eat the sacrificial meal and its components. R. Yehudah Sirleon thus argues that there is no rabbinic text that clearly forbids starting the Seder early and eating matzah and maror before nightfall. [See Hazon Ovadiah I:1 for further analysis of this position and a close reading of the printed Tosafot on Pesahim 99b and its various versions.]

R. Ya’akov of Corbeil’s approach dominates subsequent discourse, with almost all assuming that matzah may not be eaten until dark. [Aside from those preferring the substantive approach of R. Ya’akov of Corbeil, anyone who rejects the notion that biblical mitzvot tied to a specific day cannot be done before the astronomical onset of the day—אין תוספת יום טוב דאורייתא—also would not be able to accept his view. In other words, anyone uncomfortable with starting Shemini Atzeret early and eating outside of the sukkah for that late afternoon meal would not be able to rely on R. Yehudah Sirleon here. See Taz on OH 668.]

Maharil (Germany, 1360-1427) assumes a standard requiring one to wait until the stars came out to do Kiddush at the Seder, but is perplexed by this. R. Ya’akov of Corbeil’s argument only explicitly requires eating matzah after dark! Why not begin the Seder earlier, and allow Kiddush and the narrative retelling last until nightfall, at which point matzah can be eaten. He therefore explains that the Mekhilta tells us that the narrative retelling is linked to the ritual foods of the Seder. If the latter can only be consumed after dark, then the former can only be begun after dark. He furthermore emphasizes that karpas at the Seder is intended to get children to ask questions and is thus part of the narration. Therefore, this too must be done after dark. Kiddush, strictly speaking, does not need to be done after dark, he argues, but since some people do a longer Kiddush and others a shorter one, the practice emerged to wait for dark to do Kiddush as well.

R. David Abudraham is stricter: he argues that the four cups of wine at the Seder are linked to matzah and therefore cannot be drunk until after dark. Since Kiddush at the Seder is one of the four cups, it too cannot be said until after dark. Terumat Hadeshen #137 makes a similar point, insisting that the Mekhilta demands that all the rituals associated with matzah be done at a time when it is valid to eat matzah. He strengthens his argument by appealing to the midrash first advanced in Yerushalmi Pesahim 10:1 that the four cups of wine at the Seder are intended to hint at the four verbs of redemption used by God in Shemot 6, rather than just serving as anchors of a festive meal. They are thus a mythic unit that cannot be separated from the matzah and maror. [Maharil in fact challenged this logic, since it would seem to require drinking the third and fourth cups before midnight, after which one cannot consume the required matzah at the Seder, a requirement with no basis in earlier sources. Terumat Hadeshen might respond that the key for the four cups is not that they all be at a time valid for the consumption of matzah per se, but rather at night, so as to coincide with the slaying of the first born and Israel’s deliverance.] Nevertheless, this strict approach to Kiddush was not universally practiced. While R. Shimshon b. Tzemah Duran (14th-15th c., North Africa) advances this position as well in his work Yavin Shemuah, a later gloss on that work testifies that it was not common practice to wait until dark to begin Kiddush at the Seder, an effective return to Maharil’s approach. Indeed, while Shulhan Arukh OH 472 takes a strict view on starting Kiddush after dark, R. Ya’akov Reischer (in Hok Ya’akov there) notes that the logic on which this is based is challenged by Maharil and seems to favor the latter’s position. As a result, R. Ovadiah Yosef (in Hazon Ovadiah I:1) rules that while Kiddush should in fact be said after dark, when one is in a difficult situation, one can say it earlier, based on Maharil’s approach. [He goes so far as to argue that Terumat Hadeshen himself would concede this point.]

While almost all subsequent voices endorse the requirement to wait for dark even for Kiddush, some modern authorities questioned this whole line of analysis, suggesting an even more limited reading of R. Ya’akov of Corbeil. R. Yosef b. Avraham Molkho (18th c., Salonica, student of R. Yosef David of Salonica), in his work Shulhan Gavoah, asserts that R. Ya’akov of Corbeil and all other rishonim that only emphasize the importance of eating after dark would in fact permit all prior parts of the Seder to be done earlier. Only the foods directly compared to the Pesah sacrifice, and thus associated with the directive to eat it בלילה הזה, must be eaten after nightfall. But Kiddush, karpas, and the whole narrative ritual of the haggadah, can be done while it is still light out. He in fact claims that the plain language of the Tosefta only seems to be concerned about the rituals of Pesah, matzah and maror, but evinces no concern for the earlier parts of the Seder. As a result, he concludes that almost everyone other than Maharil, Abudraham, Terumat Hadeshen and Rashbatz would permit starting the Seder while it is still light and timing it to get to the eating of matzah at nightfall. Though he prefers starting Kiddush after nightfall, R. Molkho notes that this is only in deference to the Shulhan Arukh, but not because he believes this view to be correct. Hatam Sofer (in his comments on Pesahim 99b) more actively permits starting Kiddush early (possibly only after sunset, though his language there may be an imprecise way of just indicating the onset of Yom Tov) and timing the end of the hagaddah for the emergence of stars. [It should be noted that Hatam Sofer grounds this position in a fairly weak textual argument, even though the substantive position is tenable; the same can be said of R. Ya’akov of Corbeil’s position above.]

Neither of these views directly engage the Mekhilta, which seems to insist that the narrative retelling happen at the time when Pesah, matzah and maror are in play. There are a number of ways they might have addressed this text: 1) They might read the phrase בשעה שמצה ומרור מונחים לפניך to mean when you are engaged in the direct preparation for eating them. Even if it is not yet a valid time for eating them, the fact that the narrative will culminate with their consumption at the proper time is sufficient to meet this criterion. [Note that a close reading of Tosefta 2:22 suggests that it is preferable to eat Pesah, matzah and maror as close to the onset of nightfall as possible.] 2) They may view the Mekhilta as an asmakhta, as having fundamentally less authority than the explicit linkage of the Pesah offering with matzah and maror in the Torah. In other words, whereas the Torah specifies night as the proper time for Pesah, matzah and maror, it is only the Mekhilta that tries to link the narrative telling of the story to the time of the Pesah. Therefore, even if we require the telling of the story to happen on the 15th of Nisan (as opposed to on the 1st of the month or even on the 14th during the day), we don’t have a strong enough linkage based on the Mekhilta alone to require the telling to be after astronomical dark. Therefore, as long as one has ushered in the ritual frame of the 15th (by committing oneself to refrain from forbidden work, lighting candles, and/or praying Arvit), one may say Kiddush and engage in all Pesah rituals that were not specifically earmarked by the Torah for nightfall.

R. Ovadiah Yosef rejects any such deflection of the Mekhilta and assumes it establishes a strong and binding connection between the Hagaddah and matzah and maror. He therefore does not allow for any leniencies—even in pressing circumstances—for anything other than Kiddush.


The halakhic conversation surrounding the timing of the Seder is dominated by those voices that forbid starting even kiddush—and certainly everything after kiddush—before nightfall. Also note that the overwhelming consensus of almost all aharonim follows the approach of R. David Abudraham and Terumat Hadeshen as codified by Shulhan Arukh and embraces a vision of the Seder where all of its components are part of a nighttime reenactment ritual. This approach emphasizes how we are reenacting the nighttime deliverance that launched the Jewish people’s freedom and sees all the rituals of the Seder as part of that reenactment. It is therefore the most powerful model and therefore, the most preferable. Nonetheless, people often find themselves at a Seder that will start earlier than this time and can get stuck about how to proceed without causing a major family dispute. The above sources reveal a richer language for understanding a variety of practices that deviate from what emerged as halakhic consensus in most communities:

1) Accepting Yom Tov through Kiddush and starting the Seder early without concern for delaying eating matzah until nightfall. This approach is that effectively defended by R. Yehudah Sirleon, who argued that no rabbinic source explicitly contradicts this practice. This is a real outlier position in the conversation and strips the Seder experience of any astronomical connection to לילה, a key word through not only the Torah’s narrative of this story, but also the Hagaddah’s retelling of it. Given where the halakhic conversation has gone, and the plain sense of לילה in the Bible, this is essentially a deviant practice, though it has at least one defender. One at such a Seder should make the minimal effort to eat some matzah and maror after nightfall as well, even if this model is a way of understanding a family’s practice within halakhic discourse.

2) Starting the Seder early but timing the end of maggid to coincide with the emergence of stars, so that matzah is eaten after dark. This practice is validated in principle by R. Yosef Molcho and in practice by Hatam Sofer (with the latter possibly only permitting if Kiddush is begun after sunset). This approach downplays the critical nature of telling the story at the exact same time when matzah can be eaten; as long as the retelling and the ritual eating are juxtaposed and done within the same ritual time frame, there is no problem.

3) Starting the Seder early, but beginning עבדים היינו—the formal beginning of the maggid—after nightfall. While no authority I have found seems to take this approach explicitly, it is a reasonable position less radical than those above. This approach would affirm the Mekhilta’s linkage of the haggadah to the ritual eating but would balk at the deep significance of karpas, which, after all, has its origins as a typical dipping—or “salad course”—at the beginning of a meal and only later becomes invested with religious significance.

4) Starting Kiddush before nightfall but timing karpas to occur with nightfall. This conforms to Maharil’s position and is endorsed by R. Ovadiah Yosef in difficult situations (such as wanting to avoid family conflict). This approach affirms that anything done differently on the night of Pesah from another Yom Tov is inherently wrapped up with the hagaddah and thus must be part of the nighttime ritual.
5) Starting Kiddush after nightfall. This covers all opinions and reflects the assertion of Abudraham and Maharil that the Seder—which includes Kiddush as the first of four cups—is a set piece that reenacts and retells a nighttime event and thus must be done entirely at night.


AS said...

This wonderful exposition seems to be about the first seder. What about the second seder? I start the second night while it is still the first day - and serve soup and salad (a sort-of suedah shlisheet of the first day) and sing some songs, etc. THen make kiddush for the second seder after tzet and go straight from there and having a shorter meal since we already ate some... Yasher koah and Hag Kasher V'Sameah, Rabbi Lerner
- Posted by David Lerner at April 1, 2009 at 4:28pm

AS said...

My own practice on the eve of the first seder (when it falls, as it seems now always to do, after the switch to daylight savings time) (which seems different from all of the above opinions) is to begin with Urhatz and Karpas (which seems more tied to the entire season than to the evening of the 15th of Nissan), etc., and to continue on with Maggid -- which generally lasts a very long time -- until it is dark, when we stop, recite kiddush, and go back to Maggid.
I am curious whether the range of opinions would be any different if we were talking about the second seder rather than the first. On the one hand, there is the strong sense that kiddush for the second night of a yom tov should not be recited until dark; on the other hand, it is, after all, "only" the second day. Wouldn't it be even more praiseworthy "l'saper bitziat mitzraim" on the (afternoon of the) 15th of Nissan than on the evening of the 16th?

- Posted by Anonymous at April 1, 2009 at 8:07pm

AS said...

As the Rabbi of a congregation that has held a communal second night seder for many years, I have begun it at 8:00 pm, now for the second year in a row. (prior to my arrival, I think it took place much earlier) As you can imagine, many people who would like to participate, both families with young children as well as other adults, do not because of the late hour. I would like to reiterate the questions asked above regarding the possibility of starting the second night's seder during the day of the 15th, in this case to hold a community seder that is attended by a greater portion of the community.
- Posted by Josh Berkenwald at April 2, 2009 at 4:11pm

AS said...

Yishar Koach on an erudite and comprehensive discussion. We serve hot food at a "regular" time of 6:00 or 6:30 and sing songs The kids put on a play as well. In general, we do maggid and achilat matzh umaror after dark. In the past, we've waited till dark to say kiddush, but we might move that up a bit this year. Hag Kasher V'Sameah,
Rabbi Eddie Bernstein
Cleveland, Ohio
- Posted by Rabbi Ed Bernstein at April 7, 2009 at 9:06am

AS said...

A few thoughts...I believe observant Muslims can't eat for a month during the day when it's Ramadan. Good thing we aren't them. We get grouchy just thinking about eating two late meals and observing the seder rituals at night. Here in Pittsburgh where the stars come out 20-25 minutes later than in NYC, and I had a hard time convinicing my family to at least have the first seder starting at night-about 8:45. The only people that were okay with eating so late were a 12 year old and a 7 year old and their non-Jewish dad of a family we invited. I told them, imagine if it was a Steelers game on Monday night. Those games start about 8:45 and go 3-4 hours. They agreed with me that they would beg their parents to stay up late, assuring them that they would take naps earlier on Monday and promise their parents that they would be coherent in school on Tuesday even if that turned out not to be true. For our seder they did just that. And even though the seder ended after 1 and they felt tired and out of sorts the next day, they didn't complain about taking part in our seder.
All these possible leniences you mentioned here, I feel really need to be sized up with an honest cost-benefit analysis of how often todays Jews make tradtional Judaism fit their needs instead of a Jew today fitting the requirements of traditional Judaism. In my city, Pittsburgh no one cares how late the Steelers game goes. We are watching it. And when the Yankees are in the World Series past midnight, all of New York is glued to the game. When our tradition says, experience an event late at night to get a bit of a better feel of what it was like for the Israelities, then we can't do that. We just whine. The more we model the tradition to fit people instead of modeling people to fit the tradtion the less people seem to care about tradition. When will our leaders get this?
In the next article maybe we can argue to search for chametz the day before instead of the night before the seder? A 2pm search without need to look for chametz by candlelight could save a few houses from buring down in Flatbush. You could win me over with a teshuvah for that. And if you can find a way to justify havdalah at 3pm on Saturday afternoons then I could be a nicer guy and attend more bar/bat mitzvah receptions of which very few seems to start when Shabbos is over.
Jonathan Loring Pittsburgh PA
- Posted by Jonathan Loring at April 30, 2009 at 2:52pm

AS said...


Thanks for your comment. I have a few reactions:

1) I couldn't agree more with your assessment of the priorities that many people have and the ways in which they are totally out of whack. I tried to make clear in the above, but perhaps I didn't, that I am a strong advocate of starting the Seder when it gets dark for both the reasons you state (which are about discipline and commitment more broadly) and because of the symbolic power. To the extent that I could make that point more clearly, I welcome suggestions of how to do so.

2) The analysis above is primarily targeted not at people who are in charge of setting their own Seder times, but--as I stated explicitly--at people who are stuck in a situation that is not fully within their control. In my experience, there are many people who would in fact prefer to be at a Seder starting after dark who nonetheless end up in a situation where they simply can't pull that off and are faced with a stark choice of causing major family division or feeling like they are selling their halakhic integrity down the river. If you have a better way to deal with that, I am all ears, but I do think we owe it to those people and families to have something nuanced to say if at all possible.

3) You do need to acknowledge--after studying this topic in some depth--that there simply are voices in the conversation that are just not that militant about starting after dark. Last I checked, the Hatam Sofer was a pretty reputable rabbinic authority (not generally given to leniency or innovation), and the other voices cited above that diverge from the Terumat Hadeshen offer us some other ways of understanding the role of the four cups and the storytelling on the Seder night. I completely agree that halakhic consensus sides with Terumat Hadeshen and does so for good reason. But the bottom line is that there is no voice that will allow melakhah at 3 pm on Shabbat because that would destroy the essential notion of what Shabbat is and the ways in which it must end at nightfall. In the present example, there are voices that in fact challenge the notion that it is key to drink the first cup at night, in part because the aggadic frame on the halakhic practice is a bit more complex.

Thanks for reading and contributing. Don't expect an article on ending Shabbat at 3 pm anytime soon.
- Posted by Ethan Tucker at May 4, 2009 at 8:36pm

Unknown said...

Regarding the 2nd Seder: If a 2nd Seder begins quite early, far too early for Maariv, may one participate fully in the Seder and daven Maariv afterwards? And if said Seder begins so early on account of the children present who will become cranky otherwise, how can someone who would rather the Seder begin at nightfall proceed so that they feel that they have fulfilled their halakhic obligation without causing friction or discomfort, particularly in a situation where the Seder beginning so early is not the preference of the hosts (I am a guest) but is done for the children's sake?

Osama Zain said...

So Good post and i will follow you Blog and i hope to follow my blog Ancient Egyptian Gods and Goddess and see more about Min Egyptian God thanks a gain admin ,,,

Avi Spodek said...

This is a pretty old post, but I'm hoping it's still active...
I'm look for some practical application for this year's seder.
I am in Jerusalem where tzeit hakochavim is after 6:30 pm. We'd like to begin a kid-friendly seder no later than 6 pm.
Am I correct in reading the various sources that there may be "al mi l'smokh" for doing so?
Thanks for any insight/feedback and Chag Kasher V'Sameach.

Pockets of Organization said...

In keeping with this blog, and including some very young children at our seder this year, we are serving soup at 7:15, singing all the songs, and bentching licht and making kiddush at 7:40 (candlelighting time). We go on with the seder and probably will hit "Matza" at 8:40 ("nightfall") or later. If not, we'll pick something else flexible to move up so we do matazah and marror at the right time.

Anonymous said...

You always share some new ideas. I was looking for something like this websites. I found your site quiet interesting, hopefully you will keep posting such blogs.Dissertation writing service

Unknown said...

For these sorts, the rates are practically identical to that of the house credits. In any case, there is likewise a point of confinement on these variable rates. This is for keeping the rates from surpassing the point of confinement. Cash Advance

marko said...

Payday advances are known as a fast and straightforward approach to get to crisis money. However, do you know your rights and duties as the borrower of a transient loan? It is imperative you instruct yourself and comprehend your obligations as a borrower before you finish any advance. Check Cashing San-diego

Sophie Grace said...

Awesome blog about gift idea. This is exactly what I was looking for! thank you so much for posting. 192.168.l.254